|

Cartridge Alignment:
The Basics Explained
Note: This article isn't intended as a
detailed set-up guide, but rather as an overview of the
terms associated with cartridge alignment. For a more
step-by-step guide, I refer you to our article
Turntable Set-Up
When one stops to ponder the relationship of stylus to
groove, the numbers boggle the mind. Groove width on a vinyl
LP ranges from .001" - .0014" (.025mm - .035mm). Contrast
that with a human hair which measures .006" - .007" (.17mm -
.181mm) and it's amazing that vinyl reproduction works at
all, much less as well as it does. With those numbers in
mind, you quickly realize how critical cartridge alignment
becomes. The relationship of stylus to groove is incredibly
minute, requiring precise alignment, with no room for error.
Furthermore, poor alignment can lead to asymmetrical record
wear. The stylus exerts tremendous forces on the groove
walls. Though a tracking force of 1.5 grams seems rather
insignificant, when translated to the small contact area of
the stylus, we're looking at about 340 pounds per square
inch!
Now that you're afraid to go near your cartridge, be
heartened, it's not as difficult as you might think. With
the help of a few simple tools and equipped with some basic
knowledge, you can fine tune your analog rig for optimum
performance. Let's take a look at the areas of adjustment.
Vertical Tracking Force (VTF): Setting tracking
force is the very first step in setting up a cartridge
(though it will be repeated later to fine tune). The
cartridge manufacturer recommends a range (e.g. 1.75g -
2.0g) that is appropriate for their design. Too little
tracking force and the stylus will not seat properly in the
groove, too much tracking force and you'll overload the
internal suspension, resulting in a loss of performance.
Interestingly, too little tracking is more likely to
increase wear than a high setting.
More than just applying force to seat the stylus in the
groove, the correct tracking force aligns the internal
generator assembly. For a finely tuned rig, it is important to experiment within
the manufacturers recommended range to find the precise point that gives the best
sound. The amount of difference between the different
settings within the range may be significant or negligible
depending on the cartridge brand/model and the resolution of
the system to reveal the changes.
There are a number of options when it comes to tracking
force calibration, which one is best will be determined by
the quality of the system involved. A quick adjustment using
graduations on the arm or an inexpensive balance beam scale
is adequate for modest systems, but is not accurate enough
for a high end turntable set up. At that level we strongly
recommend the use of a
digital stylus force gauge.
Overhang: As the stylus tracks across the record,
it is important that the stylus remain tangent to the
groove. Setting overhang we are aligning the cartridge to
follow that ideal arc across the record. In a radial tracking tonearm, there are
only a couple of points when it actually is (null points). Without getting
overly bogged down in technicalities, there are at least a
couple of theories about where the null points should be,
and so some gauges are slightly different than others
depending on which the manufacturer thinks is best.
To set overhang, you'll need an alignment gauge. There
are a number of overhang gauges available through the years
(DB Systems, Denessen Soundtractor, Mobile Fidelity Geodisc,
to name a few).
People usually like the one they've used before, but even the simple template provided with your
turntable or tonearm are useable.
Our Note: Probably the best
alignment protractor that's ever been devised is the
Feickert Alignment System. Precise alignment is critical
and the Feickert is the best.
VTA or SRA: VTA is an abbreviation for vertical tracking angle,
SRA stands for stylus rake angle. The two terms
(while not exactly the same) are generally used interchangeably
to describe the relative angle of the stylus to the groove.
(Though I'd say SRA is the more accurate term, most
audiophiles are more familiar with VTA, so I'll stick with
it here). This angle is normally adjusted by raising
or lowering the back of the tonearm (although shims can
be used between the headshell and cartridge). Neutral VTA
is achieved when the tonearm is parallel to the record surface
(although with some arms it may be more convenient to use
the top of the cartridge body as the reference point). As
the back of the tonearm is lowered (so that the cartridge
body tips rearward), VTA becomes negative. Conversely,
raising the arm creates a positive VTA.
Correct VTA is achieved when the angle of the playback
stylus matches that of the cutting stylus used to make the
original master lacquer. Because the angle of the record
lathe cutter head (normally specified as twenty degrees,
plus or minus five degrees) varies to some degree from manufacturer to manufacturer,
we must adjust our VTA to achieve optimum
playback results. Other variables such as record thickness,
stylus shape and variations in cartridge construction, also
make VTA adjustment necessary.
Proper VTA will be achieved by trial and error through
listening tests. One should start with a neutral VTA
condition as described above, then proceed in small increments
up and down, until the best setting is achieved. As a rule
of thumb, most cartridges that I have set-up prefer a slightly
negative VTA. That is to say, the back of the cartridge
body is slightly closer to the record surface than the front.
In looking for the "sweet-spot," there are
several things to listen for. Look for the
point at which the soundstage comes into best focus, providing
maximum width and depth simultaneously. Additionally
surface noise is at a minimum and harmonics are well
balanced. You
will find (to a varying degree depending on the cartridge)
a shift in tonality. Usually a positive
VTA results in an emphasized top-end, while lowering the
setting toward negative will soften the high-end and increase
the bass. Due to stylus shape and size, some cartridges
will be more sensitive to VTA than others. Generally, the
more radical the stylus cut, the more sensitive to proper
adjustment of VTA. All cartridges however, will benefit,
at least to a degree, from proper VTA alignment.
It is important to note that vertical tracking force (VTF)
is directly related to VTA. As tracking force is increased
cantilever deflection increases, changing the relationship
of stylus to groove. So fine tune VTF before zeroing in on
VTA.
Azimuth: Even more critical (in my opinion) to proper set-up than VTA, is cartridge
azimuth. Unfortunately VTA gets all the press, therefore
many people are not aware of the importance of this adjustment.
What is azimuth? Looking at the cartridge body from the
front, it is the left to right tilt of the cartridge body.
Contrary to popular belief, azimuth is not necessarily
correct with the sides of the cartridge body are
perpendicular to the record surface. What we're actually
looking for is the correct relationship of the stylus to the
groove. Unfortunately, the vast majority of styli are not mounted
perpendicular to the bottom of the cartridge body, thus making
azimuth set-up by sight alone erroneous. And
with the current trend toward decreasing stylus size, even
seeing the stylus without the aid of magnification borders
on the improbable. The "eyeball" or "mirror"
method should only be employed if other more sophisticated
methods are unavailable.
The gold standard for determining the correct azimuth is
a dedicated cartridge analyzer or
Fosgate Fozgometer from Musical Surroundings (see below). A test
tone (typically 1kHz) is played on one channel while the analyzer
looks at the output from the opposite channel. This crosstalk
is a measure of cartridge separation. When the crosstalk is at its lowest, and equal on both
channels, the azimuth is optimized. If you can obtain a
test record, an oscilloscope or
accurate digital voltmeter can be substituted for the dedicated
cartridge analyzer mentioned above.
Lacking the test equipment previously described, other
less sophisticated methods may be employed to set azimuth.
The simplest alternative, connect one channel of the cartridge out of phase with the
other (simply reverse the + and - on one channel only)
and play a test record with a mono track or a
monophonic record (preferably one with simple
instrumentation). Out of
phase information cancels so adjust azimuth by tuning for least output.
From Harry Weisfeld at VPI comes yet another rather simple
method, requiring only a mono record and a pair of ears.
He suggests that a simple mono recording of voice should
provide a stable, non-wavering image, precisely centered
between the two speakers. Adjust the azimuth to achieve
optimum results. This method works well if youre practiced
enough to know what to listen for, though most listeners
would be better served by using one of the tests outlined
previously. Best option, use the Fozgometer.
We recommend using
the
Fozgometer to correctly set Azimuth.
From a mechanical standpoint, adjusting azimuth on some
tonearms may be difficult. Some manufacturers (e.g. SME, Rega),
in their unbending quest for maximum rigidity, have eliminated
azimuth adjustments altogether. In most cases, this doesn't
mean that you are stuck with an improperly aligned cartridge,
but it does mean that your task is a bit more formidable.
Arms lacking these adjustments must be shimmed at the base
(or the cartridge adjusted with washers) to achieve accurate azimuth.
It's a
pain, but worth the
effort.
Note: The SME IV, IV-Vi and V do not have dedicated
azimuth adjustments, but their azimuth can be changed. Simply
loosen the two base locking screws and, by firmly grasping
the bearing housing at the back of the tonearm, you can
shift the arm left-right a few degrees. While this is not
a wide range of adjustment, it will be enough to correct
for any minor cartridge deficiencies. Re-tightening the
base locking screws will lock in the adjustments. REGA tonearms
do not have adjustable VTA.
Zenith: Aligning the stylus with in the groove in
the horizontal plane dials in zenith. Looking down on the
cartridge from above, zenith is changed by rotating the
cartridge (as if around a clock face). Of course there is
only a very small amount of adjustment possible on most
arms, just the play in the mounting screws.
Zenith is best adjusted using test equipment, but one
can (assuming the stylus is correctly mounted to the
cantilever) also adjust by eye using an overhang gauge with
an alignment grid. Simply sight down the cantilever from the
front, aligning it with the directly below it on the gauge.
Anti Skate Bias: Tonearm geometry creates a force
that pulls the cartridge toward the center of the record.
Anti skate bias counteracts that force, seeking to equalize
pressure of the stylus on both sides of the grooves. Just
how to set anti skate is somewhat of a controversy.
Most all tonearms will have calibrated, adjustable anti
skating. The normal practice would be to dial in anti
skating to match the tracking force. (i.e. 2g of tracking
force and 2g of anti skating bias). However, higher
compliance cartridges are more affected by anti skating
adjustment than low compliance cartridges, so some
manufacturers suggest setting anti skating for low
compliance cartridge at about one-half to two-thirds the
tracking force, high compliance
Some suggest using a grooveless
record. but Sumiko disagrees stressing that skating is a
dynamic force and using a blank or grooveless disc will
result in over compensation.
Another method suggests lowering the
stylus into the groove while watching from the front to see
if the cartridge has a tendency to move inward or outward,
then adjusting anti skate until there is no perceived
motion.
It would be difficult to overstress the importance of proper cartridge
alignment. If you expect to get all the performance promised
by your costly investment in analog, these adjustments simply must
be made. So please take the time to insure that your arm/cartridge
combination is properly set-up. The number of dealers with
a good analog background is small. Hopefully you have a good
one in your area. If not it pays to learn the ropes yourself
to insure be sure that it has
been done correctly. Your investment in time will pay off
with the reward of better sound. Note: More information
on cartridge set-up is available in our article
Turntable Set-Up.
|